Skip to content

Sulla

Written by Gemini 4 Argon from Google Search 18 of 28 paragraphs cited

Contents

Lucius Cornelius Sulla Felix (138–78 BC), commonly known as Sulla, was a Roman general and statesman who served twice as consul and held the revived office of dictator of the Roman Republic.1 He was the first commander in the history of the late Republic to seize political power in Rome by force of arms, marching his legions on the capital twice and prevailing in Rome's first full-scale civil war.23

Rising to prominence as a subordinate to Gaius Marius during the Jugurthine and Cimbrian wars, Sulla later became Marius's bitter political rival.4 After distinguishing himself in the Social War, Sulla won the consulship for 88 BC and the command against King Mithridates VI of Pontus. When his political enemies transferred that command to Marius, Sulla marched his army into Rome, overthrew his opponents, and departed for the East. Returning victorious in 83 BC to find the rival Marian and Cinnan faction in control of Italy, he waged a second civil war culminating in the Battle of the Colline Gate in 82 BC.56 As dictator, he purged thousands of opponents through institutionalized proscriptions and enacted sweeping constitutional reforms designed to entrench the supremacy of the Roman Senate and curtail the plebeian tribunate.78910 In 79 BC, he voluntarily resigned his dictatorship and retired to private life, though the precedent of his military coups permanently destabilized the Republic.

Early life and career

Lucius Cornelius Sulla was born in 138 BC into a branch of the ancient patrician gens Cornelia that had fallen into political obscurity and relative poverty. An ancestor, Publius Cornelius Rufinus, had held the consulship twice in the early third century BC before being expelled from the Senate for possessing more than ten pounds of silver plate9; thereafter, the family did not attain the highest offices of the state until Sulla himself. Despite his modest means, Sulla received a thorough education typical of the Roman aristocracy, becoming fluent in Greek and developing a lifelong attachment to literature and the theater.11 According to the biographer Plutarch, Sulla spent much of his youth in Rome among actors, musicians, and performers, a milieu considered disreputable by traditionalist Roman nobles.12 His financial standing improved substantially when he received two timely inheritances, one from his stepmother and another from a wealthy woman named Nicopolis, enabling him to enter the cursus honorum, the formal sequence of Roman public offices, at the relatively late age of thirty.

Sulla was elected quaestor for 107 BC and assigned by lot to serve as financial magistrate under the newly elected consul Gaius Marius, who had assumed command of the protracted Jugurthine War in Numidia. Tasked with raising cavalry in Italy and bringing them to North Africa, Sulla quickly proved himself an adept military organizer and won the affection of the common soldiers as well as the confidence of Marius. By 106 BC, Jugurtha had been driven to seek refuge with his father-in-law, King Bocchus I of Mauretania.13 When Bocchus opened negotiations with Rome, Marius dispatched Sulla on a perilous diplomatic mission to the Mauretanian court. Through a combination of persuasion and calculated nerve, Sulla convinced Bocchus to betray Jugurtha and hand the Numidian king over in chains. Although Marius celebrated the triumph for ending the war, Roman aristocrats hostile to the populist consul eagerly credited Sulla with the decisive capture. Sulla fueled his commander's resentment by commissioning a signet ring depicting Bocchus surrendering Jugurtha directly to him.

Despite the growing personal friction between the two men, Sulla served under Marius again during the Cimbrian War against the migrating Germanic tribes of the Cimbri and Teutones. Serving first as a legate and later as a military tribune from 104 to 103 BC, Sulla captured the chieftain Copillus of the Tectosages and persuaded the tribe of the Marsi to ally with Rome. By 102 BC, relations with Marius had deteriorated to the point that Sulla transferred to the army of Marius's co-commander, the aristocratic proconsul Quintus Lutatius Catulus, operating in northern Italy. Under Catulus, Sulla managed the provisioning of the legions and helped lead the forces at the decisive Battle of Vercellae in 101 BC, where the joint armies of Marius and Catulus annihilated the Cimbri.

Praetorship and the Social War

Returning to Rome to advance his political career, Sulla suffered a temporary setback when he failed in his first bid for the praetorship, an outcome he later attributed in his memoirs to the electorate's desire that he first hold the aedileship and stage lavish public games. He won election on his second attempt and served as praetor urbanus in 97 BC, winning popular favor by staging magnificent ludi Apollinares that featured the first exhibition of a hundred unchained lions in the Roman circus.1 Following his year in office, the Senate assigned him the governorship of Cilicia in Asia Minor as proconsul. His primary mandate was to check the expansionist designs of King Mithridates VI of Pontus and restore the Roman client king Ariobarzanes I to the throne of Cappadocia.14 With a small Roman force supplemented by allied levies, Sulla defeated the Cappadocian factions and repulsed an invading army sent by King Tigranes the Great of Armenia, successfully reinstalling Ariobarzanes by 94 BC.

During his campaign in the East, Sulla marched to the banks of the Euphrates, where he became the first Roman magistrate to hold a formal diplomatic meeting with an envoy of the Parthian Empire, an ambassador named Orobazus.15 At the reception, Sulla ordered three chairs placed—one for Ariobarzanes, one for Orobazus, and his own in the center—thereby asserting Roman preeminence over Parthia, a gesture for which the Parthian king later had Orobazus executed. During this conference, a Chaldean seer in the Parthian retinue examined Sulla's physiognomy and prophesied that he was destined to become the greatest of men and to die at the very height of his fame and fortune. Returning to Rome around 93 or 92 BC, Sulla aligned himself firmly with the conservative optimates against Marius. When Gaius Marcius Censorinus prosecuted Sulla for extortion in Cappadocia, the charges were dropped before trial, though tension with Marius nearly erupted into violence in 91 BC when Bocchus dedicated gilded statues on the Capitol depicting Jugurtha's surrender to Sulla.

The outbreak of the Social War (91–88 BC), a massive rebellion by Rome's Italian allies (socii) demanding Roman citizenship, suspended domestic factionalism.16 Both Marius and Sulla took the field, and Sulla's aggressive campaigns in the southern theater eclipsed the more cautious operations of the aging Marius in the north. Serving initially as a legate under the consul Lucius Julius Caesar in 90 BC and then assuming sole command of the southern army after the death of the consul Lucius Porcius Cato in 89 BC, Sulla won a string of victories across Campania and Samnium. He besieged and captured Pompeii and Herculaneum, routed a large Samnite army under Cluentius at Nola—where his own troops awarded him the corona obsidionalis, or Grass Crown, Rome's highest military decoration—and seized the rebel stronghold of Bovianum. His reputation as Rome's foremost general secured his election to the consulship for 88 BC alongside Quintus Pompeius Rufus, and he cemented his alliance with the senatorial establishment by marrying Caecilia Metella Dalmatica, the widow of the princeps senatus Marcus Aemilius Scaurus and a member of the influential Caecilii Metelli family.17

First march on Rome and Mithridatic War

As consul in 88 BC, Sulla received the coveted senatorial commission to lead the war against Mithridates VI of Pontus, who had overrun the Roman province of Asia and ordered the coordinate massacre of tens of thousands of Roman and Italian citizens across Anatolia in the "Asiatic Vespers".18 Before Sulla could depart, however, the plebeian tribune Publius Sulpicius Rufus proposed legislation to distribute the newly enfranchised Italian citizens evenly across all thirty-five Roman voting tribes, a measure vigorously opposed by the consuls and the traditional aristocracy. To secure backing for his bill, Sulpicius formed a secret pact with the sixty-nine-year-old Marius, who still coveted the profitable eastern command. When Sulla and Pompeius Rufus declared a suspension of public business to block the vote, Sulpicius unleashed armed gangs in the Forum, killing Pompeius Rufus's son—who was also Sulla's son-in-law—and forcing Sulla to flee for his life, reportedly taking refuge inside Marius's own house before escaping to his six legions encamped at Nola. In Sulla's absence, Sulpicius passed his citizenship laws and pushed a plebiscite through the tribal assembly transferring the Mithridatic command from Sulla to Marius.

The march of 88 BC

Refusing to accept his deposition, Sulla took the unprecedented step of appealing directly to his soldiers at Nola. Relying on the personal loyalty of troops who depended on their commander for plunder and post-war land grants, he warned them that Marius would raise new legions of his own and deprive them of the rich spoils of the East. When military tribunes arrived from Rome to assume command on Marius's behalf, Sulla's soldiers stoned them to death. Although all of Sulla's aristocratic officers—except for a single quaestor, Lucius Licinius Lucullus—deserted him rather than lead a Roman army against their own homeland, the rank and file followed Sulla across the pomerium, the sacred boundary of Rome, which no armed force had ever legally crossed. Overcoming street-by-street resistance organized by Marius and Sulpicius at the Esquiline Gate, Sulla seized control of the capital. He compelled the Senate to declare Marius, Sulpicius, and ten other political enemies hostes (public enemies).19 Sulpicius was betrayed by a slave and executed—Sulla freed the slave for obeying the decree and then had him thrown from the Tarpeian Rock for betraying his master—while Marius escaped to exile in Africa. After annulling Sulpicius's laws and overseeing the election of the consuls for 87 BC, the conservative Gnaeus Octavius and the populist Lucius Cornelius Cinna, Sulla extracted an oath from Cinna to uphold his settlement and departed with his legions for Greece in early 87 BC.

Campaigns in Greece and Asia

Almost immediately after Sulla left Italy, Cinna broke his oath, was driven from Rome by Octavius, and joined forces with the returning Marius to seize the capital by force. Marius and Cinna instituted a bloody purge of Sulla's supporters, confiscated Sulla's property, repealed his laws, and declared him a public enemy. Cut off from reinforcements and state funding by the hostile regime in Rome, Sulla nonetheless prosecuted the First Mithridatic War with relentless vigor, financing his operations by plundering the sacred treasuries of the Greek sanctuaries at Olympia, Epidaurus, and Delphi. Landing in Epirus and marching into Attica, he laid siege to Athens—then ruled by the Pontic-backed tyrant Aristion—and its fortified port of Piraeus, held by the Pontic general Archelaus.20 After a grueling siege throughout the winter of 87–86 BC, Sulla's troops breached the walls of Athens on 1 March 86 BC, subjecting the city to a devastating sack before driving Archelaus out of Piraeus and burning the port's arsenals.

Moving north into Boeotia, Sulla confronted huge Pontic armies under Archelaus despite being heavily outnumbered. In 86 BC, using field fortifications and tactical reserves to neutralize the enemy's scythed chariots and numerical superiority, Sulla routed Archelaus at the Battle of Chaeronea. The following year, he annihilated a second reinforced Pontic army of roughly 80,000 men at the Battle of Orchomenus, driving the survivors into the surrounding marshes.21 Meanwhile, the Cinnan government in Rome had dispatched a rival Roman army under the consul Lucius Valerius Flaccus to defeat Mithridates and supersede Sulla. Flaccus was murdered in a mutiny led by his legate Gaius Flavius Fimbria, who then campaigned successfully against Mithridates in Asia Minor. Eager to have his hands free to deal with Fimbria and return to Italy, Sulla met Mithridates in person at Dardanus in the Troad in 85 BC. Under the Treaty of Dardanus, Mithridates agreed to evacuate all conquered Roman territories in Asia, surrender seventy to eighty warships, and pay an indemnity of 2,000 to 3,000 talents, in exchange for retaining his ancestral kingdom of Pontus and being recognized as a Roman ally. Sulla then marched against Fimbria at Thyatira; as Fimbria's soldiers deserted en masse to Sulla's camp, Fimbria committed suicide. Before sailing west, Sulla reorganized the province of Asia, imposing a crushing collective fine of 20,000 talents—representing five years of back taxes plus war costs—that plunged the Greek cities of Anatolia into deep debt for a generation.

Second civil war and proscriptions

After spending 84 BC in Greece resting his troops and treating a painful affliction in his feet that ancient physicians identified as incipient gout, Sulla landed at Brundisium in southern Italy in the spring of 83 BC with five battle-hardened legions, totaling roughly 30,000 to 40,000 men. Cinna had been killed in a mutiny the previous year, leaving the Marian faction under the leadership of Gnaeus Papirius Carbo, Gaius Norbanus, Lucius Cornelius Scipio Asiaticus, and Gaius Marius the Younger, the son of Sulla's late rival. Although the government in Rome fielded well over 100,000 troops, its forces were fragmented and poorly led. Upon landing, Sulla maintained strict discipline among his soldiers to win over the Italian municipalities, solemnly promising to uphold the newly granted citizenship rights of the socii. Prominent exiled aristocrats and ambitious young commanders rapidly rallied to his standard: Quintus Caecilius Metellus Pius joined him from Africa, Marcus Licinius Crassus recruited forces for him, and the twenty-three-year-old Gnaeus Pompeius (later known as Pompey the Great) raised three private legions from his father's veterans in Picenum and marched them to Sulla's camp.22

Advancing into Campania in 83 BC, Sulla defeated the consul Norbanus at the Battle of Mount Tifata and then opened negotiations with the other consul, Scipio Asiaticus, near Teanum. During the truce, Sulla's soldiers fraternized with Scipio's raw recruits and persuaded the entire consular army of forty cohorts to defect to Sulla without a blow being struck. In the spring of 82 BC, the war intensified as Carbo and the twenty-six-year-old Marius the Younger assumed the consulship.23 While Metellus Pius, Pompey, and Crassus fought Carbo's forces in northern Italy, Sulla marched toward Rome against the younger Marius, routing him at the Battle of Sacriportus and penning the survivors inside the heavily fortified hilltop town of Praeneste.2425 Before evacuating Rome, Marius sent orders to the urban praetor Lucius Junius Brutus Damasippus to murder the remaining conservative senators still in the capital, including the Pontifex Maximus Quintus Mucius Scaevola. Leaving Quintus Lucretius Ofella to maintain the siege lines around Praeneste, Sulla occupied Rome unopposed and pushed north into Etruria, where he fought an indecisive battle against Carbo at Clusium before Carbo abandoned his army and fled to Africa.

The decisive confrontation of the war occurred on 1 November 82 BC. A large army of Samnites and Lucanians—up to 70,000 men commanded by the Samnite general Pontius Telesinus and the Lucanian Marcus Lamponius, who regarded Sulla as an existential enemy of Italian autonomy—broke away from attempts to relieve Praeneste and made a forced march directly on Rome, declaring their intention to tear down the city that sheltered the "wolves" of Italy. Sulla raced south in pursuit and engaged them late in the afternoon outside the northeastern walls of the city in the Battle of the Colline Gate. In ferocious fighting that continued into the night, Sulla's left wing, which he commanded in person, was shattered and driven back against the closed city gates; ancient sources record that Sulla narrowly escaped death and prayed in desperation to a small golden statuette of Apollo from Delphi that he carried in his bosom. Only around midnight did word arrive that Crassus, commanding Sulla's right wing, had routed the enemy left and pursued them to Antemnae, turning a near-defeat into a total victory that cost an estimated 50,000 lives on both sides. Days later, as Sulla addressed the Senate in the Temple of Bellona, he simultaneously had several thousand surrendered Samnite prisoners butchered in the nearby Villa Publica; when the senators started in terror at the shrieks of the dying men, Sulla calmly instructed them to listen to his speech and pay no mind to the correction of a few criminals at his order. Soon after, Praeneste surrendered, the younger Marius committed suicide, and Sulla ordered the execution of the town's Samnite and Praenestine defenders.26

The proscriptions

Now absolute master of Rome and Italy, Sulla set out to eradicate his political enemies and replenish the exhausted state treasury through an unprecedented mechanism of legalized terror known as the proscriptions (proscriptiones).27 Rather than allowing chaotic and unorganized reprisals by his soldiers, Sulla posted official lists on whitened wooden tablets in the Roman Forum containing the names of individuals declared outlaws.28 Any person whose name appeared on the lists was stripped of citizenship and legal protection and could be killed on sight by anyone—including their own slaves or relatives—with complete impunity. The state offered a fixed bounty of two talents (roughly 48,000 sesterces) for the severed head of each proscribed man, while sheltering or aiding an outlaw was made punishable by death.29 The property of the victims was confiscated and sold at public auction at deeply discounted prices, enriching Sulla's lieutenants, freedmen, and cronies—most notably Crassus and Sulla's freedman Chrysogonus—while providing land and cash to settle roughly 120,000 of Sulla's veterans in military colonies across Etruria, Campania, and Latium. Furthermore, the sons and grandsons of proscribed men were permanently barred from running for political office or reclaiming their family estates.30

Sulla issued an initial list of eighty names, followed over the subsequent days by lists of two hundred and twenty more each, and expanded the purges across the municipalities of Italy until the lists officially closed on 1 June 81 BC. Ancient casualty figures vary, with Appian reporting that some 90 senators, 15 consulars, and 2,600 members of the equestrian order (equites) perished, while other ancient traditions place the total number of prominent victims at around 4,700. Although initially aimed at active Marian partisans, the lists quickly came to include apolitical men added solely so that Sulla's associates could seize their estates or estates could be sold to pay off debts. Among the young aristocrats targeted for refusing Sulla's demand that he divorce his wife Cornelia, the daughter of Cinna, was the eighteen-year-old Julius Caesar; Caesar went into hiding in the Sabine hills until Vestal Virgins and influential Sullan relatives interceded to win him a reluctant pardon, prompting Sulla's famous warning that in young Caesar there was "many a Marius."

Dictatorship and constitutional reforms

With both consuls for 82 BC dead—Marius at Praeneste and Carbo executed by Pompey in Sicily—Sulla instructed the Senate to appoint an interrex, Lucius Valerius Flaccus, to oversee the restoration of the government. Instead of holding immediate consular elections, Sulla wrote to Flaccus advising that the state required a dictator with plenary powers to restore order. Under the lex Valeria, passed by the centuriate assembly in late 82 BC, Sulla was appointed dictator legibus scribundis et rei publicae constituendae (dictator for the making of laws and for the settling of the constitution). The traditional Roman dictatorship had been an emergency magistracy strictly limited to six months and unused since 202 BC at the end of the Second Punic War; Sulla's office carried no fixed time limit, ratified all of his past and future actions in advance, and granted him unrestricted power of life and death, confiscation, and legislation. Celebrating an extravagant two-day triumph over Mithridates in January 81 BC, he formally assumed the cognomen Felix ("the Fortunate")—rendered in Greek inscriptions as Epaphroditus ("Beloved of Aphrodite")—to signify his conviction that his victories were blessed by divine favor.

Throughout 81 and 80 BC, Sulla enacted the leges Corneliae, a comprehensive overhaul of the Roman constitution aimed at reversing fifty years of populist agitation since the tribunates of the Gracchi brothers and restoring the unchallenged supremacy of the Senate. His primary target was the office of plebeian tribune, which populists like Sulpicius had used to bypass the Senate and strip commanders of their armies. Sulla stripped the tribunes of their power to initiate legislation before the tribal assembly without prior senatorial approval, restricted their veto (intercessio) strictly to the protection of individual citizens against arbitrary actions by magistrates rather than blocking public business, and turned the office into a political dead end by barring anyone who served as tribune from ever holding any higher magistracy in the cursus honorum.3031

Simultaneously, Sulla restructured the Senate and the magistracies to ensure that the senatorial aristocracy could govern the expanded Empire while checking the ambitions of individual governors. Because war and proscriptions had reduced the Senate to roughly 150 members, Sulla doubled its traditional size from 300 to 600 by directly enrolling 300 prominent equestrians and local Italian elites.32 To maintain this number without relying on the quinquennial censors, he increased the number of quaestors elected annually from eight (or twelve) to twenty and made entry into the Senate automatic upon holding the quaestorship. He also raised the number of praetors elected each year from six to eight. Under his lex Cornelia annalis, he codified the cursus honorum into strict statutory law: a candidate had to serve as quaestor (minimum age thirty) and then praetor (minimum age thirty-nine) before standing for the consulship (minimum age forty-two), and a mandatory ten-year interval was strictly enforced before any magistrate could hold the same office a second time. When his own loyal officer Quintus Lucretius Ofella, the conqueror of Praeneste, defied this law by campaigning for the consulship of 80 BC in the Forum without having been either quaestor or praetor, Sulla watched from a tribunal above the Forum and had a centurion cut Ofella down on the spot.

To curb the independence of provincial commanders and reform the administration of justice, Sulla passed the lex Cornelia de maiestate (treason law). While consuls and praetors generally remained in Italy performing civic and judicial duties during their year in office before departing to govern provinces as proconsuls and propraetors, the treason law made it a capital crime for a provincial governor to lead his army outside the borders of his province, start a war on his own authority, or fail to depart his province within thirty days of his successor's arrival. In the judicial sphere, Sulla abolished the equestrian monopoly on jury panels established by Gaius Gracchus and transferred control of the courts exclusively to the newly enlarged Senate. He reorganized and established seven permanent criminal courts (quaestiones perpetuae), each presided over by a praetor and dedicated to a specific category of offense: provincial extortion (de repetundis), treason (de maiestate), electoral bribery (de ambitu), embezzlement of public funds (de peculatu), murder and poisoning (de sicariis et veneficiis), forgery and counterfeiting (de falsis), and aggravated personal injury (de iniuriis). While much of Sulla's political legislation was later overturned, this system of permanent statutory criminal courts formed the enduring foundation of Roman criminal law well into the Imperial period.

Resignation and death

True to his intention of restoring constitutional government once his legislative program was complete, Sulla began stepping back from absolute rule in 80 BC, when he served a second regular consulship alongside his aristocratic ally Quintus Caecilius Metellus Pius. At the end of 80 BC or early in 79 BC, having declined re-election to the consulship for 79 BC, Sulla summoned a public assembly in the Forum, formally resigned his dictatorship, dismissed his twenty-four lictors with their axes, and disbanded his personal bodyguard. According to Plutarch and Appian, he then walked unguarded through the Forum as a private citizen, offering to render a full account (ratio) of his official actions to anyone who demanded it, before retiring peacefully to his country estate near Cumae and Puteoli on the Bay of Naples.

In retirement, Sulla withdrew from day-to-day governance—intervening only briefly to oppose the consular candidacy of Marcus Aemilius Lepidus for 78 BC—and devoted his final months to hunting, fishing, banqueting with theatrical companions, and composing his Latin autobiography in twenty-two books. Married five times over the course of his life—first to Ilia (or Julia), then to Aelia, Cloelia (whom he divorced for barrenness), Caecilia Metella (who died in 81 BC), and finally the young divorcée Valeria Messalla, who had caught his eye at a gladiatorial show during his dictatorship—he lived at his Campanian villa with Valeria, who gave birth to a daughter, Cornelia Postuma, shortly after his death.11 He finished the twenty-second book of his memoirs, which he dedicated to Lucius Licinius Lucullus as guardian of his young son Faustus Cornelius Sulla and daughter Cornelia Fausta, just two days before he died.

In the spring of 78 BC, at the age of sixty, Sulla died at his villa in Puteoli. Ancient accounts offer two distinct explanations for his death. Plutarch and Pliny the Elder report a moralizing tradition claiming that Sulla suffered from phthiriasis, a gruesome condition in which his flesh supposedly putrefied and bred swarms of lice or worms that could not be washed away. Modern historians and medical scholars, drawing on details preserved by Valerius Maximus and Appian, generally reject the worm infestation as hostile propaganda and attribute his death to acute gastrointestinal hemorrhage or liver failure—likely a ruptured gastric ulcer or esophageal varices aggravated by chronic heavy drinking—triggered when Sulla flew into a violent rage while shouting at a local magistrate of Puteoli, Granius, who had delayed paying a contribution toward the rebuilding of the Capitoline Temple in Rome. Sulla ruptured an internal abscess, vomited large quantities of blood, and died the following morning after a night of fever.

Despite an attempt by the consul Marcus Aemilius Lepidus to block a state ceremony, the other consul, Quintus Lutatius Catulus (the son of Sulla's former commander), backed by Pompey and thousands of Sullan veterans who converged on the route from across Italy, escorted Sulla's body in a grand procession on a golden bier to Rome. In the largest public funeral Rome had ever witnessed prior to that of Augustus in AD 14, Sulla's body was cremated in the Campus Martius—in accordance with his own wishes, breaking the ancient tradition of the Cornelian gens to bury rather than burn their dead, reportedly out of fear that his enemies might dig up and desecrate his corpse as he had done to the remains of Gaius Marius. On his monument in the Campus Martius was carved the epitaph he had composed for himself, which summarized his view of Roman aristocratic ethics: that no friend had ever done him a kindness, and no enemy a wrong, that he had not repaid in full.

Legacy and historical assessment

Sulla's constitutional settlement proved remarkably short-lived, largely because it attempted to solve structural crises through purely legalistic constraints while ignoring the political and military realities Sulla himself had created. Less than a year after his death, the consul Lepidus led an armed rebellion in Etruria demanding the restoration of tribunician powers and the return of confiscated lands. In 75 BC, the consul Gaius Aurelius Cotta repealed the ban preventing former tribunes from holding higher office. Finally, in 70 BC, two of Sulla's own former lieutenants, Pompey and Crassus, served together as consuls and dismantled the core of the Sullan constitution: they restored the full legislative and veto powers of the plebeian tribunes, revived the office of censor, and passed the lex Aurelia iudiciaria, which ended the senatorial monopoly on the courts by dividing juries equally among senators, equestrians, and tribuni aerarii.

More destructive to the survival of the Roman Republic than the failure of his laws was the example of Sulla's career. By marching on Rome in 88 and 82 BC, Sulla demonstrated that the post-Marian Roman legions were loyal to the generals who paid and settled them rather than to the Senate or the constitution. Ambitious commanders over the next five decades repeatedly invoked Sulla's actions as a model or justification. During the civil war of 49 BC, Pompey repeatedly exclaimed among his confidants, "Sulla could do it, why cannot I?" Meanwhile, Julius Caesar, who crossed the Rubicon in direct violation of Sulla's treason law, deliberately contrasted his policy of clementia (clemency) with Sulla's cruelty, while reportedly mocking Sulla's political judgment by remarking that "Sulla did not know his political ABCs" (Sullam nescisse litteras) when he voluntarily resigned the dictatorship. Seven years after Caesar's assassination, however, Octavian (later Augustus), Mark Antony, and Marcus Aemilius Lepidus directly revived Sulla's most dreaded innovation, instituting the proscriptions of the Second Triumvirate in 43 BC to finance their armies and liquidate their republican enemies, including Cicero.

In ancient and modern historiography, Sulla has remained an enigmatic and polarizing figure, viewed as a paradox of cold-blooded ruthlessness and conservative republican idealism. Although his own twenty-two-book memoirs were lost in antiquity, they heavily influenced the surviving narrative of Plutarch's Life of Sulla and Appian's Civil Wars, preserving Sulla's self-portrayal as a charismatic favorite of fortune who acted reluctantly to save the state from demagogues. Conversely, Roman writers of the late Republic and Empire, such as Sallust, Cicero, Seneca, and Lucan, treated Sulla's dictatorship and proscriptions as the archetypal nightmare of tyranny and civil bloodshed. Modern scholarship has similarly debated his motives and historical role: nineteen-century historian Theodor Mommsen characterized Sulla as an ironic, clear-eyed aristocrat who temporarily propped up a decaying oligarchy without personal vanity, whereas twentieth-century scholar Ernst Badian emphasized the bitter factional politics and personal vendettas driving his actions, and Jérôme Carcopino argued unpredictably that Sulla had actually intended to establish a permanent monarchy before being forced into retirement by a coalition of Pompey and the Metelli. Most contemporary historians, following scholars such as Arthur Keaveney and Karl-Joachim Hölkeskamp, interpret Sulla as a sincere, if archaic, reactionary—a "last republican" who used revolutionary violence and autocratic power in a doomed effort to restore a traditional senatorial consensus that his own marches on Rome had rendered impossible.

References

32 sources
  1. 1

    Sulla - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org

  2. 4

    Sulla worldhistory.org

  3. 5

    Battle of the Colline Gate historica.fandom.com

  4. 7

    Lucius Cornelius Sulla thelatinlibrary.com

  5. 15

    Lucius Cornelius Sulla « IMPERIUM ROMANUM imperiumromanum.plOct 31, 2021

  6. 16

    The Roman Civil War historylearning.com

  7. 17

    Sulla and Mithridates sites.ualberta.ca

  8. 19

    The Story of Sulla, the Ancient Military Commander realclearhistory.comJun 20, 2025

  9. 20

    First Mithridatic War historica.fandom.com

  10. 22

    Sulla’s Civil War - World History Edu worldhistoryedu.comJan 22, 2025

  11. 26

    Sulla's Reforms as Dictator worldhistory.orgDec 6, 2019

  12. 27

    Plutarch on lost memoirs of dictator catocensorius.blogspot.comApr 2021